Left Field

A job guarantee for some is no guarantee at all

By Daniel Emmett-Gulliver

Share
A job guarantee for some is no guarantee at all

The Pavilions, Uxbridge

Meaningful job guarantees would recognise that the right to an opportunity to work should not depend on someone’s age.

Alan Milburn’s youth job guarantee leaves the over-50s and the long-term unemployed behind and may come at the cost of cuts to young people’s benefits, writes Daniel Emmett-Gulliver.

Should you have a legal guarantee of a job or training? Alan Milburn seems to think so. But is that practical? And is it fair that it would only be guaranteed for 16–24-year-olds not in education, employment or training? Shouldn’t there be a guarantee for everyone or for no one?

Why is the unemployed person who would desperately love to work but has tried and tried and tried to get a job unsuccessfully less worthy than a fresher? Why is someone over-50 whose career has disappeared into some sort of Bermuda Triangle less worthy than a recent graduate?

Why is someone from an ethnic minority background who wants to work but find themselves judged before they have even answered a question in an interview less worthy than someone who wants to get up and at it the day after their 18th birthday? The government of the day should always be committed to optimum employment. Not welfare and work. But welfare to work.

There is something rather odd about the idea that someone aged 22 should be entitled to a legal guarantee of employment or training, while someone aged 52, who has spent decades contributing to the economy, is left to fend for themselves.

Why should the opportunity be restricted to one particular age group? Either we believe that everyone who wants to work should have a genuine opportunity to do so, or we don't.

Yes, young people deserve support. Nobody is suggesting otherwise. The transition from education into employment can be difficult especially when economic walls are crashing down all around them. And being unemployed for a prolonged period can absolutely have disastrous consequences, financially, mentally, emotionally and psychologically.

But being out of work doesn’t suddenly become less of an issue just because someone is 25, 35, or 45. For those over 50, finding another job can be an extraordinarily difficult experience. Years of experience, professional knowledge and qualifications can count for naught, or feel that way, when employers are looking for fresh talent.

And it isn’t just age. There are people who face discrimination and prejudice when applying for jobs, finding themselves having to overcome assumptions about their background before they have even had the opportunity to articulate what they can do.

Practicalities and questions to be answered

And what of the practicalities? A bad policy idea will be implemented badly. What constitutes a guarantee? A permanent job? An apprenticeship? A temporary placement? Another training course? What if the guarantee becomes another zero-hour set-up? What if employers renege on offers?

There is a world of difference between offering someone a genuine opportunity and simply finding somewhere to put them to keep the unemployment figures down. And what about adversely disincentivising those currently in the education system? And what about the education system?

Could a guarantee of employment or training act as a disincentive for some young people to work hard and achieve good solid GCSEs that stand them in good stead for their first step down their chosen career path? If a job is guaranteed, does that change the incentive to study and strive to achieve the best possible results?

There is an argument that qualifications will still matter and that a guarantee of an opportunity is not a guarantee of a particular job. That is perfectly reasonable. But is it realistic? These are questions that need answering.

And just because Milburn proposes it, doesn’t mean it will happen overnight. That is another problem. Will the guarantee be another policy proposal that is slated for Labour’s manifesto in the next general election?

And what of unintended consequences? There can always be unintended consequences when governments introduce policies that sound great on paper but then crash on impact.

There is also another political question. Is this proposal (at least partially) an attempt to pacify Labour backbenchers who may be quietly mobilising against the government’s wider welfare plans?

Milburn is also rumoured to propose that Personal Independence Payments and the health-related component of Universal Credit be scaled back for younger people. This seems to be a classic case of Labour’s giveth with one hand, taketh away with the other approach to policymaking.

What is a 16–24-year-old going to do if their financial support is cut back and they are then let down by an employer who reneges on an offer of employment or training? A guardrail on one side of a cliff edge is no good if there is nothing to stop you falling from the other.

And there are even bigger considerations and questions. How does this fit into Andy Burnham’s vision for Britain? Where does it fit into Burnham's ambition to dismantle neoliberalism? If Burnham is serious about dismantling that model, then surely this is a fundamental part of that?

And what replaces this model? There is nothing wrong with wanting to give young people a better start in life. Quite the opposite. But a universal guarantee would recognise that the right to an opportunity to work should not depend on someone’s age.

A guarantee for everyone, or a guarantee for no one. Isn’t that where the debate has to start?

Read more from Daniel Emmett-Gulliver on his Substack.

Daniel Emmett-Gulliver

Left Field · Contributor

Daniel Emmett-Gulliver

Daniel Emmett-Gulliver is a native Londoner and adoptive Welshman, who is passionate about politics, fairness and equality.

Leaving Left Field

You're visiting an external site

Left Field is not responsible for the content of external websites.