Left Field
UK

Milburn cuts are the test of Burnham’s promise to end neoliberalism, says Clive Lewis

By Left Field news desk

Share
Milburn cuts are the test of Burnham’s promise to end neoliberalism, says Clive Lewis

Clive Lewis MP website

Making young disabled people poorer won’t get them into work, Clive Lewis warns.

Labour MP Clive Lewis says the Milburn review offers a false choice on welfare. He calls it the test of Andy Burnham’s promise to end neoliberalism.

Clive Lewis has accused the government of “manufacturing consent” for a new round of welfare cuts, ahead of today's Milburn review.

The Labour MP for Norwich South said the proposals were a test of Andy Burnham's pledge to end neoliberalism. “You cannot promise to change the economic operating system while continuing to accept its most damaging assumptions,” he wrote on X and Facebook.

Alan Milburn's final report on youth unemployment, From a welfare state to a working state, is published at 11.30am today. It is expected to recommend that under-25s lose access to personal independence payment (Pip) and the health element of universal credit.

A false choice

Lewis said a “steady drumbeat” of interviews and briefings had told the public that painful choices were unavoidable before parliament had even seen the report.

He argued that Labour MPs were not the real audience. Instead, the aim was to win over commentators, think tanks and a sceptical public. Then that acceptance could be used to pressure MPs. “Persuade the public there's no alternative, then tell Labour MPs the public demands it,” he wrote.

The choice being offered, he said, was a false one – cut support for the most vulnerable, or face economic ruin. “Heads I win, tails you lose.”

Lewis compared the government’s position to the Kobayashi Maru, the no-win test in Star Trek. Captain Kirk beat it by reprogramming the computer. Lewis said Labour should do the same with the economy.

Pip is not an unemployment benefit

Lewis agreed with Milburn that too many young people are being failed. He backed calls for better mental health services, apprenticeships, training and serious upfront investment. But he said the plan contradicted itself. “If poverty, poor health and lack of opportunity are keeping young people out of work, how does making some of them poorer solve the problem?”

Pip helps disabled people with the extra costs of daily life, including costs that help them work, he pointed out. Taking it away risks creating another barrier to escaping poverty. He also cited figures showing 3.1 million universal credit claimants were already in work in April. That, he said, showed an economy where work too often fails to provide security, not a country unwilling to work.

Reprogramming the system

Lewis set out what he thinks the alternative looks like. He called for fairer taxes on wealth, restored collective bargaining, and public control of essential infrastructure. He also wants new fiscal rules that allow long-term investment. Institutions such as the Treasury, the OBR and the Bank of England should serve democratically set goals, not the preferences of financial markets, he said.

“A Labour government should not be taking a penny from people who need support while leaving the structures that generate poverty, insecurity and inequality largely intact,” he wrote.

He warned the proposals felt like “the unfinished business of the Starmer government”. Burnham, he said, had promised something different. “Well, this is the test.”

Lewis was one of six left Labour MPs who wrote before publication warning that a generation risked becoming disconnected from work and society. The others were Nadia Whittome, Bell Ribeiro-Addy, John McDonnell, Apsana Begum and Richard Burgon.

Left Field news desk

Left Field · Contributor

Left Field news desk

Left Field’s news desk covers breaking stories and developments across UK and world politics, housing, and public services – reported fast and reported straight.

Leaving Left Field

You're visiting an external site

Left Field is not responsible for the content of external websites.